![]() |
||
Caramel Cookie Recipe"Frosted with a basic butter icing"
This caramel cookie recipe is from my Italian grandma's 1932 tin recipe file.
It's one of those drop cookie recipes - which has a few extra things that are a surprise...like sour cream! I know what's a caramel cookie doing with sour cream? I dunno. It's my grandma's recipe, so I keep it in. And I LOVE the extra "oomph" it gives. Italian Dessert Recipes call for nuts - and this cookie didn't leave it out. So be a purist and don't skip this - you'd hate yourself. You'd lose the texture and have zero flavor. So grind away. I had my family sample two different frosting's on this cookie. And, I stuck with the original frosting penned in my grandma's beautiful handwriting. It's the basic butter frosting listed below an "extra" - but it adds to caramel cookie flavor. Remember this caramel cookie recipe a soft cookie with nutty overtones and a brown sugar flavor. It's not a chewy caramel. If this wasn't exactly what you were looking for - check out my home page of Italian Dessert Recipes, and I have all my Italian cookies listed below. Thanks for stopping by - Lisa Caramel Cookie RecipeWith basic butter frosting YIELD: 4 Dozen Ingredients * 1/2 cup of shortening * 1 1/2 Cups of brown sugar * 2 eggs * 1/2 tsp of baking powder * 1/2 Cup ground nuts (walnuts taste awesome) * 1 tsp soda * 1/2 tsp salt * 2 1/2 cups of flour * 1 tsp vanilla * 1 cup of sour cream Procedure * Preheat oven to 400 degrees * Cream shortening and brown sugar * Add eggs * Add sour cream and blend * Add vanilla * Combine dry ingredients * Add to batter * Bake for 10 minutes * Drop by rounded teaspoons on greased cookie sheet. Cookies will be "puffy" Frosting * 6 tablespoons of butter * 1 1/2 cups of powdered sugar * 1 tsp of vanilla ( I also tried almond flavoring - too strong!) NOTE: I doubled this to get thicker frosting. Can I use butter instead of shortening?Yeah. I actually hate shortening - BUT out of respect to my grandma, I made this the way she
wrote it.
A trick to baking with butter and not getting frisbees? Chill the dough so it's cold. Drop the cold dough on a cookie sheet. It works! I prefer shortening, what other recipes on this site use it? Not a whole lot. But if you cook vegan I know shortening is a major part
of vegan recipes. Here's some:
How come no pecans? You "can" use pecans.
We just don't use them in Italian dessert recipes.
Walnuts and almonds are the most popular nuts in our recipes. But these will turn out fine if you
do use pecans.
Is the sour cream necessary?Not sure what it would taste like with out it. To me, it really
adds a nice flavor. Is this a chewy cookie?This caramel cookie recipe taste caramel like - BUT it is not chewy at all! Just
caramel in flavor.
Back to the top of this Caramel Cookie Recipe
Almond Butter CookiesAmaretto Cookies Almond Cookie Recipe Anisette Cookies Apricot Bars Bourbon Ball Recipe
Breakfast Cookie RecipeBrown Sugar Cookie Recipe Butterscotch Bars Cappuccino Cookies Caramel Cookie Recipe Cherry Chocolate Bars
Chocolate Cookie BarsChewy Ginger Cookies Chocolate Raisin Cookies Chocolate Macaroons Chocolate Mint Cookies Coconut Macaroon Cookies
Coffee BrowniesCornflake Cookies Date Cookies Date Bars Eggnog Cookie Recipe Florentine Cookies Gingerbread Cookies Recipe
Homemade Granola RecipeItalian Fig Cookies Italian Wedding Cookie Recipe Kourabiedes Lemon Cookie Recipe Lemon Shortbread Recipe
Meringue Cookie RecipeMint Brownie Recipe Best Oatmeal Raisin Cookies Orange Cookies Pizzelle Recipe Pumpkin Bars Ricotta Cheese Cookies Rum Ball Recipe Sesame Seed Cookies Sour Cream Cookies
Superbowl Sunday is coming up! The best Italian Dessert Recipes for a party like this are ones that are:FAST Finger Foodish (not big hunky sticky globs of gooey-ness that get on your furniture) And freeze-aheads A couple of my favs for this are Cappucino Cookies (lots like choc chips but with a twist) Anisette Cookies (Always on the top 5) Rum Balls (Gingersnaps and Rum) Let's not for get the drinks to go with the beer that will be present! Check out my Italian drinks section for that. Lisa
Would you like to share this page? You know how to do it!
Thanks for sharing the sugar love!
|
||
|
Recipes on this site are
from family cookbooks, family traditions, or intentional adaptations from traditional recipes to add an Italian flair. If a recipe
was adapted or used from another cook - it is mentioned on the recipe page and the recipe author is given credit.
| ||